What Sky’s WAR gets wrong about family law

Back to blogs


Sky’s legal drama WAR makes for compelling television, but how accurately does it portray the realities of family law practice? Reflecting on the programme’s depiction of mediation, adversarial tactics and the commercial pressures facing law firms, Grace Parry challenges some of the stereotypes surrounding family lawyers and considers how Resolution members take a more constructive approach to acting in their clients’ best interests.


WAR, Sky’s new legal drama starring Dominic West and Sienna Miller, follows the acrimonious divorce between high-profile CEO Morgan Henderson and international film star Carla Duval. The show centres on two prestigious law firms, each determined to secure the best possible outcome for their client. It is full of intense negotiations, tactical manoeuvring and emotionally charged disputes. The show’s title itself reflects the conflict that can arise during highly contentious divorce proceedings.

Episode 2 of WAR centres on mediation between Morgan and Carla in an attempt to resolve financial matters arising from their divorce swiftly, privately and without court intervention, avoiding any unwanted media attention. Both parties attend mediation supported by their respective legal teams. They are placed in separate rooms, with the mediator moving between them, communicating offers and counteroffers. This approach is known as shuttle mediation.

Rather than focusing on constructive negotiations and realistic proposals with the aim of reaching a settlement, mediation is portrayed as highly adversarial, with both parties’ legal representatives seeking to capitalise on perceived weaknesses and use the process to strengthen their client’s position. The show highlights the determination of each law firm to secure the best outcome for their client, prioritising tactical advantage over constructive resolution.

 

One of my concerns about the programme is that it could reinforce a stereotype of family lawyers as aggressive, adversarial and intent on promoting conflict. Litigation can be costly, both financially and emotionally. In WAR, Carla Duval’s firm is portrayed as struggling financially, with a suggestion that they must secure a victory for Carla to keep the firm afloat.

Whilst the commercial pressures of running a law firm are real, I found this aspect uncomfortable as it reinforces the misconception that family lawyers are driven by fees rather than their clients’ best interests. Admittedly, it does make for better television, but it bears little resemblance to the approach taken by most Resolution members, who focus on achieving the best outcome for their clients in the most constructive, cost-effective way possible.

As a Resolution member, I am a strong supporter of mediation and the constructive role it can play in helping parties resolve disputes. As a form of non-court dispute resolution (NCDR), mediation provides a confidential setting (subject to certain exceptions) in which parties can explore practical solutions with the support of an independent mediator, while reducing conflict and potential costs.

Shuttle mediation, as depicted in War, can be particularly helpful where direct communication between the parties is difficult. However, not all cases are suitable for mediation, and careful consideration needs to be given to issues such as domestic abuse, safeguarding concerns and material non-disclosure.

Whilst WAR portrays mediation as another form of battle, the reality is often very different. For many separating couples, mediation provides an opportunity to step away from conflict, regain control of the process and reach practical arrangements tailored to their family’s specific needs.

Although WAR is undeniably entertaining and captures some of the intensity of family law practice, it presents a version of the profession that is far more aggressive than the one I recognise. As a Resolution member, I found myself repeatedly wincing at tactics designed to amplify hostility rather than resolve disputes.

In my view, clients are better served by working with them constructively and focusing on the bigger picture. It is not the role of a good family lawyer to ‘win’ every battle, but rather to guide their clients through exceptionally difficult periods with integrity, honesty and professionalism, helping them to achieve the best outcome in their circumstances.

While the lawyers in WAR may think they are acting in their clients’ best interests, some of their underhand tactics suggest otherwise.

Grace Parry is an associate at Myerson and a Resolution-accredited family law specialist

[email protected]

Find out more about Resonate

Write for the blog