How might cohabitation reform look in practice?
And how can we make sure the public understand the reality of any changes?
Over the past few months, the main topic of conversation amongst family lawyers has been the government’s consultation on “A fairer end to relationships”. While the consultation remained open, discussion focused on whether the proposals for amending the family law frameworks were suitable and truly reflected the changing needs of society. As the consultation reached its closing date, conversations really moved into the reality of what reforms would mean for people going through separation, and the media started to reflect the variety of opinions from real people with lived experience.
In Graeme Fraser’s article he sets out the proposals and Resolution’s response. Here I want to focus on some of the proposals for cohabiting couples and potential practical realities for amicable dispute resolution should reforms be brought in.
Proposals for cohabitation reform
The myth of the common law marriage is one of the most prevalent misconceptions in family law. On an almost daily basis, most family lawyer will speak to clients who believe that, based on the length of their relationship, or the fact they have children together, they are in a quasi-marriage like relationship and have financial rights upon separation. The reality that this is not the case shocks many, and can have serious consequences, either upon leaving a relationship where they have no entitlement to claims over property, or forcing financially vulnerable parties to remain in abusive and unsafe relationships.
The proposals to offer qualifying cohabitants some rights on separation (and if their partner dies intestate) is part of the government’s wider campaign to halve violence against women and girls (VAWG) in the next decade, as well as minimising financial instability upon separation.
The qualifying criteria for unmarried couples suggested includes living together for a period of three years or sharing a child (or a “child of the family”). The court must be satisfied that the couple has been in an “enduring family relationship” to be considered for rights under reformed structures. This has not been qualified further than “romantic, committed, long-term interdependent relationships” and the government has called for wider views on what factors a court should consider in determining the level of commitment. Suggestions currently include:
- existence of a joint household
- responsibility for children
- public recognition of the relationship
- presence of a sexual relationship
Proposals also suggest that there be a time limit of two years post-separation to financial claims being brought. This would allow sufficient time for those deciding whether to bring a claim, but does not leave the option open indefinitely, which would cause instability. As with divorce proceedings, the best option is to provide finality for all parties.
Financial claims would be managed according to the “needs” principle, as in divorce proceedings. This has been proposed as a model to align with four key principles:
- “Needs” focus on the welfare of any children – the primary caregiver would have their housing and living needs met in line with their caregiving responsibilities, to enable as much stability as possible for children moving forwards
- Protecting women in cohabiting relationships – recognising the fact that many women have reduced or no earnings due to caregiving responsibilities as well as the gender pay gap, a needs model would ensure they are able to secure housing and a reasonable standard of living
- Preservation of marriage as a distinct status – needs would be defined more narrowly than in divorce proceedings, exclude discretionary needs, and no starting point of a 50/50 split
- Clarity and accessibility – as the needs principle is already established in financial proceedings on divorce, this would help clients and advisers to understand probable outcomes (supported by a narrower approach than in divorce)
Practical realities for cohabitants going through separation
There are significant nuances within these proposals that cannot simply be brushed under the carpet. Every family is unique, and every family breakdown looks different. The challenge for those responding to the “A fairer end to relationships” consultation has been to balance all the various experiences of clients into a suggestion that best suits the majority – whether this is possible remains to be seen.
Cohabitation laws should not be “marriage by the back door”
In reality, many couples have actively opted out of marriage or a civil partnership, knowing the consequences of both married and unmarried separation. Keeping financial portfolios unentangled is important for many people, particularly for the younger generation, who may have more financial awareness from social media and the internet. There are also families where protecting generational wealth is essential, and getting married could potentially put this in harms ways, especially in a framework where prenuptial/postnuptial agreements are not currently legally binding.
In blended families, parents want to keep inheritance ringfenced for their children from a previous marriage or relationship. Opting out of marriage, and ensuring a clear will is in place, are the securest ways of managing this.
Reforming cohabitation laws could put these types of families at risk of financial interdependence that was never intended, particularly if the essential information is not disseminated clearly and early enough to minimise risk. There would also need to be clear methods to opt-out (as the government has suggested) and safeguards against coercion.
Furthermore, should reform be implemented, there must remain a distinction between the rights married couples are entitled to on divorce, and those attributed to separating unmarried couples. The government proposed in the consultation that there be a much narrower definition of needs, whilst the court would still have access to a broad range of remedies, including property adjustment orders, lump sum orders, and pension sharing orders. While this is sensible, and offers the protection desperately needed, there is a danger that people may see this as an open door to claims similar to those of divorcing couples. A “marriage by the back door” opportunity might be created here, which could be dangerous both for parties and for the courts.
Protection for vulnerable individuals
On the other hand, it is evident that some structure is needed for cohabitees on separation. The currently lack of framework leaves people who have spent decades building a life together, sharing finances, raising children and often sacrificing careers in order to look after the household, with no recourse. There is a clear disconnect between family structures and family law, with over 3.5 million couples living together unmarried.
For parties who are financially dependent, living in abusive relationships, or those who have contributed financially, practically and emotionally to a long-term relationship, financial and legal recourse will most likely be very welcome. Even where their name is not on the legal documents for the house, an assessment of housing needs will mean a healthier prospect for financially dependent parties, and of survivors of abuse. The foundation of a clean break in divorce is to allow parties to go their separate ways without any financial or practical ties holding them together. These reforms, should they be made law, will enable separating cohabitants to – ideally – achieve the same result.
The government has assured through the consultation that potential law reform is not about putting cohabitation on an equal footing with marriage, and marriage and civil partnerships should continue to come with additional rights and responsibilities. However, the court should have discretion to rectify an imbalance where one person has become financially disadvantaged through the choices made throughout a relationship.
Litigation risk
One of the main questions we ask now is whether any reforms would increase litigation, pressurising an already full-to-bursting court system and forcing vulnerable people down roads they never intended. The challenge the government may have, if reform is to be on the cards, is how to ensure the qualifying criteria are clearly communicated, and in plain English, so the general public can understand in what circumstances rights might apply.
Education and client support
Education remains central. Many individuals will be unaware of any potential changes, and may still be clinging to their “rights” as a common law spouse. This will require sensitive, but decisive advice from practitioners.
As family lawyers, we have a responsibility to safeguard our clients’ interests as effectively as possible, and that includes providing clear and honest advice. Families need certainty during periods of relationship breakdown, and this is where the role of the lawyer is essential – helping clients navigate the current legal framework and ensuring it works as effectively as possible for their circumstances.
Where possible, disputes between separating cohabitants should still be directed to resolution methods such as mediation, or collaborative law, avoiding court wherever safe to do so. Family law professionals also have a responsibility to encourage holistic support for clients, regardless of marital status, on family breakdown. Ultimately, separation can cause the same pain, regardless of marital status.
Ciara.Pugh@stowefamilylaw.co.uk